Should You Pay Off Credit Cards or Loans First?

Light bulb icon.

Quick Answer

  • Paying credit cards off first usually maximizes your savings since credit cards typically charge higher rates than loans.
  • Lower card balances can also reduce your credit utilization rate, which can help your credit scores.
  • Payday, title and past-due loans are the exception and usually should be prioritized.
A happy couple in the sun in front of their car, pulled over on the shoulder of a remote mountain highway.

In general, it's best to pay off credit card debt first, then loan debt, since credit cards often have higher interest rates and fluctuating payments. In addition to saving money, prioritizing your credit card balances can also improve your credit utilization, which can bolster your credit score.

That said, there are some exceptions to the rule. Here's what to keep in mind as you figure out how to tackle your debt.

Why It's Usually Best to Pay Off Credit Card Debt First

It's usually better to focus on credit cards first when paying off debt because they charge higher interest rates, and your card balances have more impact on your credit score than your loan balances.

Less Interest to Pay Off

Credit cards typically charge higher interest rates than most forms of consumer credit. For context, here's a look at the average rates for the most common debt types:

Average Interest Rates for Different Types of Consumer Debt
Credit cards19.49%
Personal loans13.48% (36 months)
14.61% (60 months)
Auto loans11.19% (used)
6.35% (new)
Mortgage loans7.43% (30-year fixed)
6.60% (15-year fixed)

Sources: November 2026 data from Curinos LLC; auto loans: Q2 2026 data from Experian's State of the Automotive Finance Market report

As you eliminate higher-interest balances first, you'll pay less in interest over the course of your repayment plan.

Of course, there are some exceptions to this rule. For example, the typical payday loan charges an effective annual percentage rate (APR) of nearly 400%, and auto title loans charge APRs around 300%. Even some online personal loans can charge APRs upwards of 100%. If you have one of these types of loans, it's important to prioritize paying it off before tackling your credit cards.

Also, if you're behind on loan payments, getting caught up before switching to your credit card debt can help minimize future damage to your credit score.

Best credit cards of 2026

Compare cards from our partners with intro bonuses, cash back or points offers, and annual fees as low as $0.

Offers from our partners

Blue Cash Everyday® Card from American Express logo.

Blue Cash Everyday® Card from American Express

Intro bonus:
As High As $200 Cash Back. Find Out Your Offer.

Intro APR:0% on Purchases and Balance Transfers for 15 months

Ongoing APR:19.74%-28.74% Variable

Rewards:
1% - 3% (cash back)

Annual Fee:$0

Wells Fargo Active Cash® Card

Intro bonus:
$100

Intro APR:0% intro APR for 12 months from account opening on purchases and qualifying balance transfers

Ongoing APR:18.74%, 24.74%, or 28.74% Variable APR

Rewards:
2% (Cash Rewards)

Annual Fee:$0

Blue Cash Preferred® Card from American Express logo.

Blue Cash Preferred® Card from American Express

Intro bonus:
As High As $300 Cash Back. Find Out Your Offer.

Intro APR:0% on Purchases and Balance Transfers for 12 months

Ongoing APR:19.74%-28.74% Variable

Rewards:
1% - 6% (cash back)

Annual Fee:$0 intro annual fee for the first year, then $95.

Reflex® Platinum Mastercard® logo.

Reflex® Platinum Mastercard®

Ongoing APR:35.90% Fixed

Rewards:
N/A

Annual Fee:$75 - $125

Credit One Bank® Secured Card

Ongoing APR:29.99% Variable

Rewards:
1% (cash back)

Annual Fee:$0

Costco Anywhere Visa® Card by Citi

Ongoing APR:18.99% - 27.49% (Variable)

Rewards:
1% - 5% (cash back)

Annual Fee:$0

First Progress Prestige Secured Mastercard® Cash Back Rewards

Ongoing APR:13.74% Variable

Rewards:
1% - 10% (cash back)

Annual Fee:$49

Credit One Bank® Platinum Rewards Visa® Card

Ongoing APR:29.99% Variable

Rewards:
1% (cash back)

Annual Fee:$39

See all our best credit cards for 2026.

Reduced Temptation to Spend

Paying off a credit card and taking it out of your regular financial rotation will mean you're less likely to build up debt again. Of course, it's usually better for your credit to avoid canceling credit card accounts, though it may be worth it if the temptation to rack up more debt is too strong.

But if you can, consider using the card only sparingly or for one subscription payment, and avoid adding unnecessary charges going forward.

Strengthened Credit Score

When you pay down credit card debt, your credit utilization decreases. That ratio measures your credit balances compared with the amount of your credit limits, and it contributes to roughly 30% of your FICO® ScoreΘ.

There's no specific threshold where your credit utilization causes your score to drop significantly, but the lower it is, the better.

Learn more: What Is the Best Credit Utilization Ratio?

When It Could Make Sense to Pay Off Loans First

Prioritizing credit card debt is a good rule of thumb, but there are some instances where it makes sense to focus on loans before your card balances:

  • You have high-APR loans. Whether it's a payday loan, title loan or short-term personal loan, eliminating a higher-APR loan first can be a better financial choice. It could also help you escape a cycle of reborrowing, which is common with payday and title loans.
  • You have an introductory 0% APR promotion. With a 0% APR promotion, your card purchases won't accrue interest until the end of the promotion, typically between six and 21 months. This only works, though, if you can afford to pay off most or all of the card balance before the promotional period expires. Otherwise, you'll end up with an expensive balance anyway.
  • You're behind on a payment. If you fall behind on loan payments, it could damage your credit score. If it's a secured loan, such as an auto or mortgage loan, you may also risk losing your vehicle or home. Even with an unsecured loan, the debt could be sent to collections, and you could be sued for payment. All of these potential consequences will typically outweigh the value of interest savings.

Learn more: What to Do if You're Sued by a Debt Collector

Which Loans Should You Pay Off First?

Similar to the credit card payoff process, the best approach with installment loans is to focus on loans with the highest interest rates or APRs.

This is the general order based on average interest rates. Be sure to check your actual APRs, since your own loan terms could vary.

1. Payday Loans

Payday loans typically cost more than any other type of debt, and their short repayment terms can make it easy to get caught up in a cycle of reborrowing. The same is true for auto title loans, but those carry even more risks because you could lose your vehicle.

Learn more: Alternatives to Payday Loans

2. Personal Loans

Personal loans typically carry the highest rates among traditional installment loans, and the rates can be much higher than average for subprime borrowers. For example, many top lenders charge APRs as high as 36%, and some online lenders may go even higher.

3. Private Student Loans

Private student loans tend to cost more than federal loans because their rates are based on your credit profile and income—though that might not be the case for parents and graduate students with excellent credit.

Still, private loans may carry variable interest rates, which can potentially increase over time (all federal loans come with a fixed rate). Additionally, private loans don't carry the same protections as federal loans, such as forgiveness programs, income-driven repayment plans and generous forbearance and deferment options.

4. Federal Student Loans

Federal student loan interest rates are generally less expensive than private loans, especially for undergraduate students without a credit history or a thin credit file. They also offer several protections, making them less urgent than private loans.

For example, if you're eligible for a lower payment on the repayment assistance plan (RAP), and your payment isn't enough to pay your monthly accrued interest, the government will cover the unpaid amount.

5. Car Loans

Car loans tend to charge more moderate interest rates than personal loans because they're secured by your vehicle. In some cases, the rate may even be lower than your mortgage rate.

That said, an auto loan is usually significantly smaller than a mortgage loan, making it more practical to pay it off first, so you can free up cash flow more quickly.

6. Mortgages

Mortgages often carry some of the lowest interest rates, and they are usually your largest balance by far. Their size makes it unrealistic for most borrowers to prioritize a home loan over other types of debt, and in many cases, you could get a better return on your extra cash if you invest it instead.

Tip: The average rate of return on the stock market is historically 10% annually. If your mortgage rate is below that, it may be worth doing the math to determine whether your projected savings on the mortgage will outweigh any potential investment returns you'd make.

Learn more: Should I Pay Off My Mortgage Early?

How to Pay Off Debt

If you have several credit cards and loans, first make a list of your current balances, APRs, minimum monthly payments or installment payments and due dates. That will help you figure out how to begin your payoff journey. Here are a few paths you can take:

  • Debt avalanche method: The most cost-saving payoff method is to target the credit card with the highest APR first, also known as the debt avalanche method. Using this strategy, you pay as much as you can on the highest-rate credit card or loan while you pay the minimum on the rest of your debts. Once you pay off the first account, you'll move to the one with the next-highest rate and use the same strategy until all your accounts are paid off.
  • Debt snowball method: With the debt snowball method, you'll focus on paying off smaller balances first. Doing so usually won't save you as much money as paying off debts with the highest APRs first. However, paying off accounts more quickly can give you a series of small wins and keep you motivated.
  • Balance transfer credit card: If you have good or excellent credit, you may qualify for a balance transfer credit card. These cards offer introductory 0% APR promotions, allowing you to move one or more balances to a single card and pay off the debt interest-free. If you have a remaining balance at the end of the intro period, though, you'll end up paying the card's higher standard APR on whatever is left.
  • Loan refinancing: If you have good or excellent credit, refinancing a car loan, mortgage or student loan could allow you to secure better terms than what you currently have. If you then also pay off the loan quickly, you'll save even more in interest compared to your original loan.
  • Debt consolidation loan: Similar to a balance transfer credit card, a debt consolidation loan allows you to roll one or more debts into a single personal loan with a fixed monthly payment. You can use one to pay off credit cards, other loans or both. For debt consolidation to work, the interest rate should ideally be lower than the average rate of your current debts. That's why it's most likely to pay off if you have good credit.

Frequently Asked Questions

It's best to prioritize the debts that are costing you the most. For most people, this means the balance with the highest interest rate. But for some, it may be a debt that's causing other issues, such as a high risk of reborrowing or a looming repossession, foreclosure or lawsuit.

Focusing on the highest-interest debt first, also known as the debt avalanche method, is usually best if you want to maximize your interest savings. In contrast, you may consider paying off your smallest balances first if you need some encouragement to keep going. Meanwhile, your highest balance only deserves priority if it also carries your highest APR.

The Bottom Line

The biggest and most important step is deciding to put your attention toward debt payoff in the first place. Once you've gotten there, keep it simple by focusing on your balances with the highest interest rates first, which will generally be credit cards. The same interest rate strategy applies when you're determining the best order in which to pay off your loans.

Since this approach helps you save money on interest, you'll be able to free up cash to put toward other debts—and financial goals even beyond debt paydown. While you work on paying down your debts, be sure to monitor your credit and keep an eye out for the changes in your credit scores.

Find out what debts you owe

Your free credit report lists all your debts, such as credit card balances and loans, helping you create a plan to tackle your debt and improve your financial health.

Review your credit
Promo icon.

About the author

Ben Luthi has worked in financial planning, banking and auto finance, and writes about all aspects of money. His work has appeared in Time, Success, USA Today, Credit Karma, NerdWallet, Wirecutter and more.
Read more from Ben

Explore more topics

Share article

Experian app.

Download the free Experian appCarry trusted financial tools with you

Download from the Apple App Store.Get it on Google Play.
Experian's Diversity logo.

Experian’s Inclusion and BelongingLearn more how Experian is committed