What Is a Discount Broker?
If you're looking to invest in stocks, bonds or other securities, you'll need to work with a brokerage firm to execute trades. A discount broker charges lower commissions and fees than traditional full-service brokers, making it a cost-effective option for investors who want to manage their own portfolios without personalized investment advice.
If you're considering a discount brokerage, here's what to know about how they work, the pros and cons and how to choose the right one for you.
What Is a Discount Broker?
A discount broker is a brokerage firm or individual that executes buy and sell orders for clients at lower fees than traditional full-service brokers. Discount brokers focus on executing client trades and generally operate online with no physical offices, which allows them to have lower commissions than full-service brokers.
Unlike full-service brokers who provide comprehensive financial planning services, discount brokers typically offer an online trading platform that allows you to research investments and place trades independently.
But while you won't get a full range of services, some discount brokers provide robust research tools, educational resources and advanced trading platforms to help do-it-yourself (DIY) investors make informed decisions.
Learn more: How to Start Investing With Just $100
Invest Your Money Smarter
Browse top brokerages
Find a brokerage to start investing today. Compare offers with sign up bonuses and low or no fees.
Full-Service Brokers vs. Discount Brokers
Understanding the differences between full-service and discount brokers can help you choose the right option for your investment strategy and needs.
Full-service brokers provide comprehensive financial services, including personalized investment advice, portfolio management, tax planning and access to research reports. They cater to investors who want professional guidance and are willing to pay a premium for these services.
In contrast, discount brokers offer low-cost, straightforward trading services, focusing primarily on individual retail investors through online platforms. They provide the tools you need to execute trades independently, but they rarely offer personalized advice.
| Full-Service Brokers | Discount Brokers | |
|---|---|---|
| Services | Personalized investment advice, portfolio management, financial planning, tax strategies, retirement planning and estate planning | Trade execution, online trading platform, basic research tools and educational resources |
| Fees and commissions | Typically 1% to 2% of assets under management; may also charge commissions on individual trades | Generally low or $0 commission for stocks and exchange-traded funds (ETFs); other assets may include transaction fees |
| Target clients | Investors who want professional guidance, have complex financial situations or prefer a hands-off approach | Self-directed investors who are comfortable making their own investment decisions and want to minimize costs |
| Tools and research | In-house research teams, analyst reports, dedicated financial advisors and comprehensive market analysis | Self-service online platforms may include charting tools, market data and investor education materials |
Pros and Cons of Discount Brokers
Before choosing a discount broker, weigh the advantages and potential drawbacks to determine if this type of brokerage aligns with your investment goals and experience level. Here's what to consider.
Pros
-
Lower costs: Discount brokers typically offer stock and ETF trades with no commissions. Compared to a full-service broker's fees, these savings can add up significantly over time, especially for active investors who make frequent trades.
-
Complete control: You maintain full autonomy over your investment decisions and portfolio composition. This independence allows you to follow your own investment strategy without relying on a broker's recommendations or timeline.
-
Low account minimums: Some discount brokers have no minimum balance requirements to open a brokerage account. This accessibility makes it easier for new investors to start building their portfolios with whatever amount they can comfortably invest.
Cons
-
No personalized advice: Discount brokers rarely offer personalized financial planning or tailored investment guidance. You're responsible for making all investment decisions without professional input on whether those decisions align with your financial goals.
-
Steeper learning curve: DIY investing requires you to understand market basics, investment strategies and risk management. Beginners may find it challenging to trade independently without guidance.
-
Potential for costly mistakes: Without professional oversight, inexperienced investors may make emotional decisions during market volatility or fail to properly diversify their portfolios, potentially leading to significant losses.
Should You Work With a Discount Broker?
Discount brokers work best for investors who are comfortable managing their own portfolios and want to minimize costs. For more context, a discount brokerage may be right for you if you:
- Have investment knowledge and feel confident making your own trading decisions without professional guidance.
- Are an active trader who makes frequent trades and wants to avoid commission fees eating into your profits.
- Follow a buy-and-hold investment strategy and don't need ongoing personalized advice.
- Want complete control over your investment decisions and portfolio composition.
- Are comfortable researching investments and analyzing market trends on your own.
- Have straightforward financial goals without complex tax or estate planning needs.
- Prefer to save money on fees and are willing to invest time in managing your portfolio.
On the flip side, you may want to skip discount brokers if you:
- Are new to investing and don't have time to research investments thoroughly.
- Have complex financial situations involving estate planning, significant tax considerations or multiple income streams.
- Prefer a hands-off approach and want someone else to actively manage your investments.
- Feel overwhelmed by investment decisions and would benefit from professional guidance.
- Want personalized financial advice tailored to your specific goals and risk tolerance.
- Need comprehensive services like retirement planning, tax strategies or wealth management.
- Value the peace of mind that comes from working with a dedicated financial advisor.
Learn more: What Investments Can I Buy Through a Broker?
How to Choose the Best Discount Broker
Finding the right discount broker requires careful evaluation of your needs and comparison of available options. Here's what to consider:
- Evaluate your investment needs. Determine what types of investments you want to trade—stocks, bonds, ETFs, options, real estate or cryptocurrencies—and ensure the broker supports those assets. Consider your trading plans and whether you need advanced charting tools or just basic functionality.
- Compare costs and features. Review a discount broker's fees before you start investing. Look beyond stock trading commissions to examine options contract fees, margin rates, account transfer fees and any subscription costs for premium features. Some brokers advertise commission-free trading but charge higher fees elsewhere.
- Review the trading platform. Test the broker's platform through a demo account if available. The interface should be intuitive and provide the research tools you need. Check if they offer both web-based and mobile platforms, and whether advanced features like real-time quotes and market analysis are included or cost extra.
- Consider customer support. Even self-directed investors occasionally need help. Research the broker's customer service options, including phone support hours, live chat availability and response times. Read customer reviews to understand the quality and reliability of their support.
- Assess educational resources. Quality brokers provide educational content to help you improve your investing skills. Look for brokers offering webinars, articles, video tutorials and market analysis that can support your investment education.
Learn more: How to Choose the Best Online Broker for You
The Bottom Line
Discount brokers offer an affordable way to invest in the stock market by providing the essential tools you need to execute trades without the high costs associated with full-service brokers.
While you won't receive personalized investment advice from a discount broker, you'll benefit from lower fees, complete control over your investment decisions and access to robust online trading platforms. The key is ensuring you have the knowledge, time and confidence to manage your own portfolio effectively.
What makes a good credit score?
Learn what it takes to achieve a good credit score. Review your FICO® Score for free and see what’s helping and hurting your score.
Get your FICO® ScoreNo credit card required
About the author
Ben Luthi has worked in financial planning, banking and auto finance, and writes about all aspects of money. His work has appeared in Time, Success, USA Today, Credit Karma, NerdWallet, Wirecutter and more.
Read more from Ben